The Itinerant Golfer

The Itinerant Golfer's Take on Fishers Island Club


Fishers Island Club

Architect: Seth Raynor & Charles Banks
Year: 1926

20449 East Main Street, Fishers Island, New York 06390
(631) 788-7223

driving range available
motorized golf carts and caddies available
public and charter ferries available to the island


It’s a beautiful sunny day with a perfect temperature in the upper 60s, I’ve arrived by boat to one of the most beautiful spots I’ve ever seen and I’m about to play one of the world’s top rated golf courses. This is one of those moments in my life where I ask myself the question “How in the heck did I get here?”

In this particular instance “here” is the 1st tee at the Fishers Island Club located on Fishers Island, NY. At the time of this writing Fishers Island Club is ranked #11 on the Golf Digest 100 Greatest Golf Courses in America list and considered one of the finest spots in the world for a game of golf. From what I’ve seen in my first 15 minutes on the island it’s already pretty tough to dispute that claim.

Fishers Island is a 7 mile long and 1 mile wide island that is home to one of the most exclusive clubs in all the land, Fishers Island Club. The Fishers Island story begins in 1614 when it was “discovered” by a Dutch explorer. The island was purchased from Native Americans in 1644 and was used primarily for farming and as a private hunting and fishing preserve from that time until the late 19th century. In the 1870s everything on the island changed when the second owner of the island’s heirs began selling lots and summer rental cottages began popping up. The island rapidly became a popular tourist destination from that time through 1889 when two prominent businessmen purchased nine-tenths of the island for $250,000 with the intent to turn it into an exclusive summer resort which stopped the steady flow of tourists that had been visiting Fishers Island.

Golf was first played on the island in 1897 and ten years later in 1907 the island’s first club, Hay Harbor Club, was established. In 1925 the eastern two-thirds of the island was acquired for the purpose of a development project that would include home sites as well as a Seth Raynor designed golf course. On July 1 the following year the club opened for business and the rest, as they say, is history. Fishers Island and Fishers Island Club became an exclusive getaway for the wealthy.

So, back to my question of how did I get here, to Fishers Island Club specifically. This is not the type of place that an average person like me finds themselves playing golf. The club had been on my radar for quite some time. Surprisingly I had learned that there were a number of members who lived in my hometown, Richmond Virginia, and belonged to the same club that I do. I did not know any of the Fishers Island members directly, but was optimistic that I might have a mutual friend with one of them and an opportunity to play may come up. That never came to pass so I just put Fishers Island on the back burner until another time.

During the course of my Top 100 quest I have literally met dozens of new people who are either well wishers, supporters, sponsors/hosts, general golf nuts or some combination of all the above. One of the folks I’ve met along the way is a fellow named Hans who hosted me for a game at The Country Club in Boston. Hans is just as much of a golf nut as I am and has played about as many of the Top 100 courses that I have. He is an enthusiastic golfer with a love and appreciation for great golf courses who also happened to know a member at Fishers Island. One day as I sat in my office wishing I was somewhere playing golf I received an email from Hans. As I read through the contents of the email I nearly missed the final line which stated “Want to come up for Fishers Island on 10/7?” Of course I gave a resounding yes and immediately booked my flight as the date was less than a month away.

Getting to Fishers Island is no simple trip. The only way onto the island is by boat as there are no bridges from the mainland. The best place to catch a boat is out of New London, CT. There are no flights into New London, so I was going to have to either fly into New York City and drive two and a half hours or fly into Boston and drive a little over two hours. Coming into Providence is another option but from Richmond there are no direct flights so that makes New York or Boston the only logical choices. I elected to fly into Laguardia and rent a car for the drive to New London.

Once in New London there are multiple options for the boat ride to Fishers Island. There is a slow moving ferry that runs on a regular schedule and drops it passengers on the end of the island farthest from the club. From there the ferry riders need to catch a cab over to the golf course. The second choice is to hire a water taxi that will shuttle four players to the east end of the island where the club has a boat dock just off the 17th green. This takes considerably less time and is definitely the favored option.

So I landed at Laguardia the night before we were to play, picked up my rental car and hit the road. Without a hitch I reached my New London hotel in a little over two and half hours. Well, there was a slight hitch. Hans emailed me late that night to say he was going to have to work the next day and that he and his friends were not going to be able to make it. Uh oh, this is not good. After about 45 minutes of driving and being bummed out about having to spend my day at Fishers by myself I got another email saying that he was just kidding. I was relieved and returned to my previous state of anticipation and excitement. What a prankster.

The hotel where I stayed was just a few blocks from the dock where we would meet the water taxi in the morning so I was all set. The next morning I woke up, had a hearty breakfast and drove to the dock to meet the other guys. Hans and two of his buddies from The Country Club, one of whom was a Fishers Island member, had left early that morning from Boston and were scheduled to arrive around 7:45AM.

At the dock we unloaded our gear, drove the cars to the parking deck, hopped onto the boat and were on our way in no time. It was a small boat and moved much quicker than the ferry, but it was not exactly a high speed watercraft and it took us a good 30 minutes to reach the dock on the east end of the island. Below is a picture of the boat. I’m thankful that the waters were not choppy as it would have been quite a ride in this little guy.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Upon arrival we walked up the dock to a spot just off the 17th green where the club had left golf carts for us to drive to the clubhouse. The weather was shaping up quite nicely and I shed my windbreaker that I had been wearing on the boat ride over. Below is a photo of the clubhouse which was built in 1964 after the original clubhouse burned down. Ironically, the club had tried, unsuccessfully, to demolish the clubhouse with dynamite just a few weeks before the fire.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Our host Chip checked us in and we headed down to the practice green to roll a few putts while we waited for our turn to tee off. There is a driving range available but is a little distance away and not used very often. I’m usually a trunk slammer at home, so that didn’t bother me a bit.

As we walked down to the practice green I caught my first real view of the coastline from on the island. Spectacular. The practice green alone was one of the most beautiful golf spots I’d ever see. Below are a couple of photos.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Fishers Island Club
 
When it was our turn we headed to the 1st tee and were off. I’m going to try something different and do my course comments in a little different format. We played from the 6,544 yard blue tees which play to a par of 72.
 
Hole 1 – Raynor’s Start – 396 yards – Par 4
Here we have a nice start with a fairly lengthy par 4 that features a wide fairway with some moderate undulation. The photo below was taken from the tee.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The front of the green is void of hazards which allows for approach shots to be run up onto the green. The bunker on the left is fairly deep and can be a problem for players who find themselves in it.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a view across the 1st green towards the 2nd tee.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 2 – Redan – 172 yards – Par 3
The redan hole is one of Raynor’s infamous template holes and is named after the original redan at North Berwick in Scotland. Typically what makes a hole a redan is a bunker at the front left side of the green and a putting surface that slants from the front right to the back left. The photo below was taken from the tee box here and the lighting makes it pretty tough to see the flag. The green on this redan hole is not quite as pronounced as some of the others I’ve seen.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Here is another look at the 2nd green from the 17th tee. The slant is more visible here and Raynor was clearly more subtle with this one than some of his others.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 3 – Plateau – 335 yards – Par 4
As I often say on this website I love short par 4s and this one is no exception. A 200 yard shot is all that is necessary to get into position for a short iron or wedge into the green. The ideal line is to play the drive right over the walking path towards a rock in the distance that is not visible in the photo below. Choosing a line too far to the right on the drive runs the risk of not reaching the fairway.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Here is a closer view of the hole with the group in front of us standing on the green.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The photo below is what the approach shot into the 3rd green looks like from the fairway. Its a little uphill so it may be wise to play a little extra yardage, especially if there is any wind . . . and there usually is.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
And below is a photo of the glorious view from atop the green on this hole.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The same view from another angle.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Note the severity of the drop off around the green in the photo below. Being long here can easily lead to bogey or worse.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 4 – Punch Bowl – 397 yards – Par 4
The punch bowl is a dyed in the wool template hole at Raynor’s courses and Fishers Island has one of the best. The drive requires a somewhat substantial carry in order to reach the fairway as illustrated in the photo below.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The approach shot into the green will likely be blind and require the use of the directional flag shown in the photo below in order to find the green.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Players living on the edge, quite literally the right edge of the fairway, might have a less obstructed, but more dangerous shot into the green as shown in the photo below. Note the rocky beach out to the right below. Chip told a story about one day hitting his drive WAY out to the right which he was certain would result in dropping a ball and taking a penalty stroke. When he reached the area to begin looking for his ball one of his playing partners found it sitting in the middle of the fairway in perfect position after being deflected off the rocks on the beach. Talk about a members bounce!
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The punch bowl green certainly lived up to its name as can be seen in the photo below.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
And in this photo . . .
 
Fishers Island Club
 
And in this one too. I really like the double flags and shadows in this one. All these photos are clickable, so just click to see a larger view.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 5 – Biarritz – 207 yards – Par 3
Another tried and true template hole at Raynor courses is the biarritz. This is a par 3 with a large swale in front of the green. It may be that when the hole was designed that the swale was actually in the middle of the green but today most of these holes do not have the front pad mowed to putting green height which places the swale at the front of the actual putting surface. The biarritz at Fishers Island plays uphill which is something that I had not seen before. I feel safe saying that there is not another biarritz hole out there that has as beautiful a setting as the one at Fishers Island Club.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Here is a little closer look at the green which shows the swale a little better.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 6 – Olinda – 520 yards – Par 5
The first par 5 on the course is the 6th hole. As shown in the photo below the drive requires a small carry to reach the fairway and is to a blind landing zone. The ideal line is right down the middle towards the trees in the distance.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
This is a tough hole to reach in two not only because of the distance, but also because the hole climbs uphill as it nears the green. The photo below was taken from where I hit my third shot.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a look back down the hole at the undulating fairway.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 7 – Latimer – 363 yards – Par 4
The 7th is one of the more picturesque holes on a course loaded with picturesque holes. Note the lighthouse out in the water behind the green. This lighthouse chimes continuously and is audible from nearly every spot on the course. I couldn’t figure out what it was when I first heard it. It was making the same sound that an Mac computer does when it receives an email,so for the first couple of minutes I heard it I thought someone had an iPhone in their bag getting emails every 30 seconds. The scrubby area off to the right is a pond and is definitely in play off the tee. This tee box is also the spot where players can use the halfway house phone order service to request a Fishers Island signature peanut butter, jelly and bacon sandwich. Its sounds strange, but it is unbelievably tasty. I guess bacon really does go with everything!
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a photo of the approach into the green.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 8 – Road Hole – 465 yards – Par 5
The 8th hole is the first of two short par 5s that actually play as par 4s from the black tees. From what I could tell the only real difference between the blue and black tees is that the 8th and the 18th both play as par 4s which makes the course a 6,544 yard par 70 rather than 72.

The drive shown in the photo below looks much more intimidating on camera than it is in reality. A well executed drive certainly helps, but we were able to find balls that missed the fairway on both the left and the right. The left is probably a little less forgiving than the right. One bad bounce on the gravel path and a ball can kick badly left.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a photo of the green at the 8th hole. This is Raynor’s Road Hole template and there is the requisite green side bunker, but it is not as severe as the original at The Old Course. Unfortunately its not really visible in this photo.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 9 – Double Plateau – 364 yards – Par 4
I think the tee box at the 9th hole, pictured below, is very cool. Believe it or not this is the original tee box. At first I thought it was was something done in modern times in order to lengthen the hole, but Chip confirmed that it is indeed the original tee box. The surrounding area is wetlands and the club would NEVER be allowed to build a tee box like this today. As a matter of fact, Chip pointed out how uneven the tee box was and how much it needed to be leveled. Because of its wetlands status the only thing the club is allowed to do is cut the grass. Any disruption of the dirt on this tee box would bring all sorts of environmental regulations and restrictions so the club is forced to keep it as is.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a view from the tee box. The drive is to a blind landing zone and the ideal line is just over the aiming post in the middle of the fairway.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is the vista that greets us as we walked over the hill . . . a gorgeous two tiered green and a short iron approach.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Here is a little closer look. I love the boats cruising by in the back ground. I suspect in the height of summer there are dozens of boats out there making quite a cool scene.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
And here is a close up view of the double plateau green.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 10 – Knoll – 401 yards – Par 4
This hole has a generous fairway and runs straight uphill which makes the hole play a little longer than the yardage on the scorecard.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The green here sits on top of a hill and definitely requires a little extra consideration when pulling a club for the approach shot.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a view looking back down the hole at the fairway.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 11 – Eden – 164 yards – Par 3
The 11th hole is another of Raynor’s template par 3 holes, this one being an eden. The green sits on the edge of the island and is one of the prettiest par 3s I’ve seen. I found it a little difficult at times to focus on hitting solid golf shots when there is so much beauty all around to soak in.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
And here we have a little closer look.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 12 – Winthrop – 389 yards – Par 4
I loved the 12th hole which is another par 4 that plays uphill to a very difficult green. With the firm and fast conditions at Fishers Island Club a little extra run in the fairway goes a long way to shortening the approach shot.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a photo of the 12th green. Note that the left side of the green is considerably higher than the right. There is also a significant mound in the middle of this green that makes long putts quite treacherous.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The putt from Chip’s location on the side of the green in the photo below was a nasty one and with the greens running around an 11 on the stimp meter it was no small task to get it anywhere close to the hole. This shape and contour of this green makes it a bit of a reverse redan.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Here is a look back down the fairway of the 12th hole and across the 13th fairway. The views here are absolutely unbelievable. The water is visible from every single hole on the course. It really is a breathtaking setting for golf.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 13 – Waterloo – 400 yards – Par 4
The drive on this hole is fairly straight forward and hitting down the middle is the ideal play. In comparison with the last couple of holes played this one fairly flat.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
The approach into the green on the 13th hole requires a carry over water to a heavily slanted green moving from front to back and left to right.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 14 -Cape – 425 yards – Par 4
The cape hole is another of Raynor’s templates. The photo below was taken from the tee box and the ideal drive favors the left side of the fairway for the shortest shot into the green.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is the shot into the green from about 180 yards out.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
And here is a closer look at the green.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
This photo doesn’t really highlight any features, I just kind of like it.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 15 – Long – 533 yards – Par 5
The drive here is to a blind landing zone and it is best to keep it down the middle as there is serious native grass on both the left and right sides of the fairways that can gobble a golf ball right up.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a photo of the green at the 15th hole. With no bunkers in front it is pretty receptive to a long second shot that lands short and bounds its way onto the green for a chance at an eagle putt. At 533 yards hitting the green in two is for the long hitters or when the wind is favorable.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 16 – Short – 146 yards – Par 3
Raynor pays homage to the short hole at The Old Course in St. Andrews with his template at the 16th. I loved this tricky little par 3 with it green sloping back to front and the hole location at the front of the green. We played this hole twice and we had three players who’s ball went from on the green to off the front of the green in one fashion or another. I thought this was a fun hole that played considerably more difficult than it looked. The backdrop for this hole is pretty amazing as well.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Here is a closer look at the green, although this photo does not do the slope justice.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 17 – Coast Guard – 415 yards – Par 4
The 17th is a fairly straight forward hole that plays fairly long at 415 yards. The drive requires a short carry over a body of water which is really more of a visual intimidator because it shouldn’t be an issue for most players.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a photo of the green which again, does not have any bunkers in front. Fishers Island Club is known for playing firm and fast which is great considering that’s how Raynor designed it. As suggested earlier in this post there are a lot of greens at Fishers Island that will readily accept a running shot.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Hole 18 – Home – 452 yards – Par 5
The 18th hole is the other par 5 that plays as a par 4 from the black tees. Since we were playing from the blues we got to play it as a three shotter. Hans and I won the match on the 17th hole and then both proceeded to duck hook our tee shots into the exact same place on the beach in front of the tee box. We all got a big laugh out of that.

The best idea here is to just hit it straight out in the middle and give yourself the best chance you can to hit the green on the second shot.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Below is a photo of the approach shot. Unfortunately I don’t have one of the green which is a pretty tricky one. The hole was cut in the far left where the group in front of us is standing. This hole plays very tough as a par 4 and very friendly as a par 5.
 
Fishers Island Club
 
Once we finished up our game we did my number 1 favorite thing to do after a round of golf . . . play again. Chip went up to the pro shop to check in and within five minutes of finishing we had balls in the air for our second round of the day. It always amazing to me how different the second time around feels after having picked up on some of a courses nuances. We ended up running a little short on time and had to cut our second round short by a 2 holes. When we finished up and got to the dock by the 17th green our boat was right there waiting for us as promised. We jumped in and hightailed it back to the mainland so I could get on the road to New York City and catch my 9:15PM flight. I ran into some traffic in Connecticut that slowed me down, but with some NASCAR-esque maneuvers I managed to make my flight just in the nick of time.

Sitting on the plane back to Richmond I flipped through the photos on my camera and marveled at what an incredible day it had been. The golf course, the beautiful setting, the perfect weather and the great playing companions. I think I can safely conclude that my Fishers Island Club experience is one of the best days of golf I’ve ever had. No question about it, Fishers Island is indeed a special place.

I’m not sure what it is about Seth Raynor courses that I love so much. Raynor was an engineer by trade which is very easy to see when examining his golf courses. His designs have many geometric features and sharp edges which are in direct contrast to the rough and natural minimalist designs from Coore & Crenshaw and Tom Doak that I’ve grown so fond of. I do believe there is something to the clubs that have Raynor courses. The ones that I have played all had a similar low key, understated, no nonsense, pure golf vibe to them. Fishers Island Club, Yeamans Hall Club, Chicago Golf Club, Shoreacres, Camargo Club . . . all of these places have great club cultures AND Seth Raynor designed courses. Probably just a coincidence, but maybe there is something to the correlation. Regardless of what it is that makes me like Raynor so much I have continued to be smitten with his designs and Fishers Island has definitely been added to my list of places not to be missed and to play as often as possible.

  • Ryan

    Steve,

    Just re-read this one, what a beautiful course. FYI the biarritz at St. Louis CC is played as one entire green with the swale in the middle of the green. Not a fun putt when you hit the front part to a back pin position. Its called Double Plateau on the card for some reason, but its the biarritz hole.

  • Ryan,

    Interesting note. St. Louis CC is one of the places that is on my short list of courses to visit. I hear it is fantastic. I hope I get a chance to see that biarritz hole. There aren’t many that are mowed to green height in the front and back.

    • Ryan

      Let me know when you think you can make it to St. Louis. I can arrange for a round

    • John Barroll

      Thats a course to die for..where can I find a current list of members?

      • The Itinerant Golfer

        Fishers Island is incredible. As far as I know there is no published list of members.

  • Barry

    Steve – Fox Chapel Golf Club near Pittsburgh also mowes to green height in the front and back. Fox Chapel Golf Club will host this year’s Constellation SENIOR PLAYERS Championship, one of the five majors of the Champions Tour in late June.

    • The Itinerant Golfer

      Haven’t been to Fox Chapel, but I hear it’s great. I need to get up there one of these days.

  • I am the Chairman of the Greens Committee at Waialae Country Club in Honolulu (Raynor circa 1927)and we are exploring a restoration of our course as close to Raynor’s original design as possible. Your pictures of Fishers Isalnd and Yeamans Hall are appreciated, as I am going to visit them in a few weeks to take pictures and to talk to the staff about their courses. Would like to establish some direct e-mail contact with you to see what resources you may have.

  • Mike W

    One more for Raynor’s with a Biarritz mowed to green height in the front and back…Elkridge Club.

  • Harry

    You should have stayed another day and played The Course at Yale, but I guess you can’t have it all. Playing both of them together gives you an interesting idea of Raynor’s theory of course design. It is one of the wackiest (and fun) courses I have ever played. Thanks for the review as always.

    • The Itinerant Golfer

      Harry,

      I wish I could have played Yale. I’m planning to get back up there and visit Yale one of these days. I love Seth Raynor and am interested in seeing as many of his courses as possible.

      Steve

  • Chris

    Great pictures of Fishers Island. I played there back in September; one of my co-workers is a member there. Phenominal course.

  • Pingback: The Fishers Island Club and its Golf Links « The Itinerant Golfer()

  • John L

    If you go back to the island charter a boat from Spicers in Noank, 10 min ride dock to dock. Also try to play the Hay Harbor course. I think it is the greatest 9 hole I ever played.

    From looking at your photo’s it seems the wind was a not an issue. Bringing 3 – 4 clubs to the tee box, not being able to put the ball on a tee, waiting for the ball to stop moving before you putt, gauging the wind by how much the pin is bending, hitting the ball 30 – 35 yards off line and watch the wind bring it back. If you can play this course on a windy day you’ll either give up the game or walk off the 18 th green with a big smile and and shake your head often over the next few days.

    • The Itinerant Golfer

      John, we didn’t have any wind at all the day that I was there. It was a perfect fall day. With the course’s exposure to the wind I can only imagine what its like with a 30mph wind blowing!

  • Andy

    The Old White TPC at the Greenbrier in WV also has a full biarritz hole mowed to green height. I think Raynor gets an assist on that design as I believe the course design is attributed to C.B. Macdonald. Great write-up

  • Chris C

    Great review of Fishers! It was my incredible good fortune to play the course on two, beautiful, warm and clear days in October, 2014. The first day the wind was blowing 30-40 mph. Absolutely brutal. Almost unplayable for me. Day 2 the wind had calmed down to 10-20 mph making it much more playable… but still very difficult. Would love to see the touring pros play the course in windy conditions. Although I heard it was not uncommon to run into one of the touring pros occasionally at this incredibly private and anonymous course; and one well-known touring pro was there one of the days we played. I think I was told that the course record is only 63 despite its relatively short length. Shooting par in 30 mph winds (which apparently are not that uncommon) would be an accomplishment indeed. The greens are fairly fast but I was told they could not be cut much faster because balls would not stay on the greens on windy days. In any event, my only criticism of John’s tremendous review above is that it severely understates both the beauty and difficulty of the course. I could comment on every hole but I will pick one; the one called punchbowl and suggest it as one of the great holes in the world. No matter how far a pro can drive it they would be crazy to attempt to drive punchbowl in a tournament leaving the hole to be played like us plebeians. In fact, many of the holes at Fishers are classic risk reward holes with risk generally greatly outweighing the reward. Like the Cape hole. After watching the BMW at venerable, but compact Cherry Hills a couple weeks before playing Fishers, I believe Fishers would hold up equally well if an Open was played there; especially in the wind. Of course no pro tournaments are apparently ever played at this Area 51 of great courses. Too bad most of the golf world misses out seeing Fishers… but great fortune for those who have gotten to play it! Thanks for the great review, John!

    p.s. I also got to play the 9 hole course called Hay Harbor and it’s a great little course. The 2nd hole at Hay Harbor, paralleling the ocean, has got to be one of the best par 4’s one could ever imagine.