The Itinerant Golfer

The Itinerant Golfer's Take on Chicago Golf Club


Chicago Golf Club

Architect: C.B. MacDonald / Seth Raynor
Year: 1894 / 1923

25W253 Warrenville Road , Wheaton, Illinois 60189
(630) 665-2988

driving range available
motorized golf carts and caddies available
on-site accommodations

U.S. Open - 1897, 1900, 1911


I am back in Chicago to play golf again and this time my friend Hayes is not with me so I wont be getting any of his Grandma’s pot roast. Too bad, that was one tasty meal. Fortunately, my friend and partner in the annual Ridley Cup golf tournament, Steve, has just moved to Chicago from Manhattan and graciously offered for me to stay at his place while I’m in town. He literally just moved having been in his house for less than 2 weeks, so the fact that his wife agreed to let me stay with them is amazing . . . especially considering that she spends her days single handedly juggling 1 year old twin girls. Thanks Wendy! My first stop while in Chicago this time is the Chicago Golf Club which is the most important golf club in America that you have likely never heard of.

So why is Chicago Golf Club one of the most important clubs in America you ask? Where shall we start? Lets see, for starters it was the first 18 hole golf course in North America and the club that established the modern Out of Bounds rule. Next, you have that the club was founded by the first US Amateur champion and de facto father of American golf, Mr. Charles Blair Macdonald. If any more evidence of the clubs importance were necessary, you can make note that Chicago Golf Club is one of the original five clubs that founded the USGA in 1894. If you’re looking for a place that has had a profound impact on golf in America, look no further than Wheaton, Illinois and the Chicago Golf Club.

And why has the golfing public at large never heard of this clearly significant and important club? Well, there are just 125 members and a great many of them play their primary golf at other clubs in the area. This results in very, very little play at Chicago Golf Club. The lack of play also means that guest invites are terribly rare, and truly something to be cherished by the lucky golfers who receive one. When I started the Top 100 quest back in 2007 I identified Chicago Golf Club as one of the five courses that may keep me from completing the quest. Everything I learned over the next three years confirmed that my fears were indeed well founded. In short, getting a chance to play Chicago Golf Club may be as likely as getting struck by lightning.

As you may remember reading here previously, Chicago is a town with a great many Top 100 courses (six at the time I am writing this) and someplace where I had very few contacts when I started this quest. I managed to stumble into one or two courses last year, but by and large Chicago is still a bit of a struggle and Chicago Golf Club, specifically, continued to be one of the more significant challenges on the list. As things tend to go with this Top 100 Quest, one of my inquiries became a lightning rod for a strike of good fortune. Against all odds, I became acquainted with a member who took an interest in supporting my quest and invited me to the club to have a game with him.

When the day arrived and I pulled into the driveway at Chicago Golf Club I was pretty excited. After parking my car I went into the locker room to change my shoes and have a look around. The first thing I noticed in the locker room were the cool subway tiled walls which were very popular in the late 1800s/early 1900s and the old metal lockers found at many of the great clubs from this era. I love a locker room with a vintage vibe so I had a good feeling about this place immediately. As would be expected the walls were adorned with golf memorabilia from the club’s history including one of the five original signed documents incorporating the USGA. It was pretty neat to see this important golf document and C.B. Macdonald’s bold signature in the flesh.

After changing into my golf shoes I wandered out to the range where I met my host, Mike, and his friend, Larry, who would be playing with us. Mike has played just about every important and significant golf course in the world so to say he is an ardent golfer and golf course architecture buff may be a bit of an understatement. I was excited to spend the day with him chatting about golf courses and golf in general.

Thursday at Chicago Golf Club is “Ladies Day” so men are not allowed to tee off until 9:30. When 9:30 rolled around there was a four ball of ladies just starting so rather than teeing off directly behind them and pushing them all day Mike suggested starting on the 16th hole which is located near the 1st tee. We started by playing 16-18 and then played 1 through 15. For the purposes of commenting on the golf course here, I’m going to go through the course starting with the first hole so as not to confuse everyone.

Before we tee off so to speak, I’ll give a very brief history of the course itself. Chicago Golf Club was founded in 1892 and at the time was located in Downers Grove, Illinois on Belmont Avenue. In early 1894 the club moved to the current location and C.B. Macdonald laid out the first 18 hole golf course in the United States. As years went by Macdonald felt that the technology of the game was advancing beyond the golf course he had created and it was necessary to redesign the course. He requested his protegee, Seth Raynor, do the work and in 1923 a new course was born. Raynor’s revisions and changes along with a handful of Macdonald’s original holes is the course that remains today.

As we prepared to start our game and discussed the tee selection there was not really much of a decision necessary as far as I was concerned. The back tees played 6,846 yards which on a par 70 course is a pretty serious test. We elected for the considerably more manageable 6,571 yard white tees.

The 1st hole is a 450 yard par 4 and is absolutely not your typical warm up starting hole. The golfer needs to be at ready from the start when teeing it up here. The photo below was taken from the tee and the best line of play is up the right side of the hole as the fairway falls off to the left.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The photo below is where I hit my approach shot from (the rough of course). I was still a good 200 yards out.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 2nd hole, pictured below, is Raynor’s version of the Road Hole at St. Andrews. This one plays 440 yards from the white tees. Anything in the middle is just great here. The approach shot will be another long one.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The photo below is of the approach shot on the 2nd hole. Note the Road Hole bunker at the front left.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 3rd hole is a par 3 Biarritz Hole that we played from 219 yards. What makes this a Biarritz is the swale just in front of the putting surface which is just slightly visible in the below photo.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Here is a closer look at the swale in front of the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 4th hole is one of the two Cape Holes at Chicago Golf Club. This one plays as a par 5 and is 536 yards long. Playing to the left of the bunker sets up the ideal second shot.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is a look from the fairway at about 180 yards out from the center of the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
And here is a closer view of the green complex. The bunker that is visible on the left side of the green actually wraps all the way around the back of the green as well as the right side. Regardless of hole location, its best to aim for the middle here.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
To the left in the photo below is more of the wrap around bunker.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
And here is a little bit more that wraps around the back side.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 5th hole is a finally a little break in the difficultly. This is a short par 4 that we played from 320 yards. The photo below was taken from the tee box.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
After a good drive just a short 60-80 yard pitch will be left to the green. This is where I finally got the message that the greens here are firm and getting shots to hold is difficult. My little wedge into the green didn’t bite and I ended up in the bunker and made double from 70 yards out. Ouch.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The photo below was taken from the 6th tee which is a 395 yard par 4. This is a fairly straight forward drive and you just want to get something in the short grass.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Here is a view to the green from about 80 yards out.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 7th hole, pictured below, is a par 3 Redan Hole which is another one of Raynor’s template holes. We played this one from 207 yards. The idea here is to hit your ball on the right side o the green and have it feed down the hill to the left where the hole location is.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is the 8th hole which is a 413 yard par 4. The line to take with the drive is over the left half of the mound where the caddies are standing.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The approach shot pictured below is fairly straight forward. There are bunkers on the right of the green and behind it so, ideally hitting the second shot from the left side of the fairway would be the best.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
At the 9th hole we’ve got a nice 403 yard par 4 hole with a carry over water to the green. You don’t find many water hazards on classic courses so it is a bit of an anomaly. The photo below was taken from the tee box.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Here is a look at the green complex from the edge of the water.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 10th hole is a par 3 that requires a carry over the same body of water from the 9th hole. It’s not really visible in the photo below, but this green is completely surrounded by Raynor’s shallow bunkers.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is a photo taken from the 11th tee. This is a 410 yard par 4 that just slightly bends to the left. The main challenge here is to avoid the numerous bunkers in the fairway and around the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
At the 12th hole we’ve got another of Raynor’s templates with this one being a Punchbowl Hole. We played this hole from 414 yards to a par of 4. The photo below was taken from the tee box.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is a look at the approach shot for this hole. Its crucial to hit your ball left of the hole location in this photo. If you go too far to the right you will find the punchbowl and have a fairly difficult putt back to the correct part of the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Here is a closer view of the green and its false front.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Its hard to see in the below photo, but the putting surface takes a bit of a dip behind the flag stick. This is the punchbowl portion of the green and you don’t want to be down there unless that’s where the hole is.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 13th hole is Raynor’s take on the very famous Eden Hole at St. Andrews. It is a par 3 and we played it from 149 yards. In the photo below you can see that there are bunkers on the front and sides of the green. They also continue almost all the way around the back.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is a photo of the 14th hole which is the last of Raynor’s template holes and is another example of a Cape Hole. This one is a par 4 that we played from 351 yards. I didn’t realize that the hole was so short until I nearly hit my driver into the bunker on the right that is just 60 yards short of the green. I probably wouldn’t have hit driver had I looked at the length of the hole, but it turned out fine and I was happy to have a short pitch to the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Here is a closer look at the green complex.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
I thought the photo below was interesting. Raynor is known for his angles and sharp edges so I thought that the way this green was cut on the corners and front was very Raynor-esque.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is the 15th hole that we played from 393 yards to a par of 4. A good drive here will carry the front bunker and stay far enough to the right to avoid the bunker behind it which is just barely visible off the left edge of the front bunker. Unfortunately, I did not do that and my ball found the back bunker and nestled up right next to the lip.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The approach shot to the green at the 15th hole.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The 16th hole which is pictured below from the tee box is a par 5 that we played from 525 yards. The ideal drive will favor the left side of the fairway.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is a view of what the second shot looks like. Just make sure you avoid both the bunkers.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
And here is a photo of the 16th green. There is a fairly significant false front here that will be a problem for approach shots that don’t quite carry far enough.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
Below is a photo of the 17th hole which is a par 4 that we played from 382 yards. There are numerous bunkers to be avoided on the right side of the hole as well as around the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
The approach shot, pictured below, shows some of the bunkering around the green. Its hard to tell from the photos, but the bunkers in front of the green complex are actually about 45 yards from the green.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
I forgot to take any photos on the 18th hole except for the green. Its a bit fitting though as the one photo I did take is of a classic Raynor feature. Note in the photo below that the corner of the green is squared off. As I mentioned before Raynor loved sharp edges and this is a very common feature on many of his courses.
 
Chicago Golf Club
 
One of the things that struck me most about Chicago Golf Club is how difficult the course was. From the tee, hitting the fairway was imperative as the native grass was so penal that hitting into it usually resulted in a lost ball and hitting your third stroke from the tee. The greens were as firm as can be and I lost track of how many times my approach shots landed on the putting surface but ended up the bunkers that are found around many of the greens. Apparently, I’m not the only one who thinks the course is hard because the course rating is 72.1. That’s more than 2 strokes above the par of 70. Luckily for me I caught fire coming down the stretch and parred 4 of the last 5 holes to tie Mike and beat Larry in our little King of the Hill game we were playing. I could hardly wait to spend my 50 cents!

Something else I found of great interest about Chicago Golf Club is that the course is built on completely flat land. This is clearly noticeable from my amateur photos above. It is hard to catch the nuances of this course and really show its genius in photos taken from ground level by someone with no photography experience like me. I’ve often read statements from the builders of golf courses that the most important piece of the puzzle is having a great site. At Chicago Golf Club Macdonald and Raynor did not. They were not able to rely on breathtaking vistas or undulating terrain so they had to use good old fashioned strategy to make an interesting golf course and I believe they succeeded in spades. Tee to green the course is a challenge, but the real scoring at Chicago Golf Club is done on and around the greens. Mike is fond of saying that the soul of a golf course is the greens and I think that is certainly the case here.

After we finished playing the three of us had lunch in the men’s grill adjacent to the locker room and continued a great discussion about playing golf, golf course architecture and the future of the game. I left the clubhouse that day with a renewed enthusiasm for giving back to this great game that has given so much to me. Chicago Golf Club is a very special place and I was very lucky to have an incredible day there with a couple of great guys. What an amazing journey this has been and I’m barely halfway finished.

  • Ryan

    Even before reading your photo comments at this end of the article, I thought “Funny how unremarkable this course looks from the tees.”

    I caddied here, and luckily played here on Mondays.

    It’s such a tougher course in August when the greens are fast versus April/May.

    Last week I played at a newly opened desert/mountain course in a planned residential community. Lots of people were raving about it, but I was unimpressed. Every tee was really far from the prior green, carts were necessary, no real continuation in the course, just very inauthentic. That’s what I love Chicago Golf Club. It’s so natural and it’s brilliance is so subtle.

    Also funny you mentioned the ’50 cent’ bet, none of the members here ever play for anything more than a couple bucks a round. Definitely a humble, old-school classiness to this course. It’s definitely not a “party” country club, it’s simply a place to modestly play golf, enjoy a simple meal in a classic clubhouse, and go along with your day.

  • Tim

    Is the course really as flat as it looks?

  • Tim, This course is not as flat as it looks in the photos, but it is certainly not a course that has dramatic elevation changes. I thought the real genius, and what makes this course special, was the bunkering and the green complexes.

  • Pingback: Fishers Island Club « The Itinerant Golfer()

  • Pingback: Yeamans Hall Club « The Itinerant Golfer()

  • Pingback: Bob O’Link Golf Club « The Itinerant Golfer()

  • No pictures of that wonderful view of the clubhouse from the course? Man, how perfect does that clubhouse fit with the course? Sublime!

    • The Itinerant Golfer

      Mac, Unfortunately I didn’t get any photos of the clubhouse from the course. I always forget to do that! It’s a real shame in this case because the clubhouse is so unique. When you factor in the history it’s one of the absolute best.

  • Pingback: U.S. Open Golf Courses « The Itinerant Golfer()

  • Jeff Engquist

    I was fortunate to grow up in Wheaton and was a caddy here for several years. Played High School golf in Wheaton and will always fondly remember Mondays when I got to play this wonderful track. The head pro at the time was Don Stickney. Hope to get another round in sometime in the near future.

  • Steve

    Itinerant Golfer, please email me for some information about a special item from the CGC, thanks.

  • Pingback: A Unique Golf Artifact « The Itinerant Golfer()

  • Joe

    Nice summary, as a former caddie there for about a dozen years you did a good decent job describing it however I do not think you emphasized the false fronts and intricacies of the greens enough. Holes 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, 12, and 16 all have significant false fronts and all the greens have subtle and not so subtle ridges that run through them that make 2 putting for par nearly impossible (if you are lucky enough to avoid the bunkers and get there in regulation anyways).

  • Jack Taylor

    Ha! Very jealous AND you got to play with Mike Keiser who is kind of a big deal. Cheers.

  • John O’Neill

    I caddied for Don Sticky in the Western Open (in ’77 I believe). Although he didn’t make the cut, he did get what I believe was the first hole in one at Butler on the challenging 5th hole. But it wasn’t official as it was a practice round and he hit several balls to the hole. Later Bob Hope got a hole in one on the same hole and they put up a plaque. I was amazized that Don, being so slender a short of stature could hit the ball so well. It proved to me that the swing ins more about timing and leverage than muscle or size.

  • youraway

    Wonderful story and one that reminds me of a game and history that is passing us by. This is what golf was all about, so wish I could enjoy such history and love for the game in my area of the country. My course regretfully plowed under our beautiful William B Langford greens to encourage easier maintenance and save money. So sad.